Two weeks ago, I sat with a group of child care professionals just entering the profession, and everyone felt overwhelmed. Whether parenting or working as an early care practitioner, the task of accompanying a human being in the first years of life is daunting! And it can seem like if you don’t dedicate an entire facility to child-sized furniture, pursue the latest and greatest in curriculum and materials, or spend every spare moment reviewing current research about proper technique, supporting adequate growth is impossible!
Thankfully, there is incredible power in small changes. Today, I offer four simple changes we can all begin right now that will have lasting impact on our relationship with children over a lifetime.
Simple Change #1: Say “You did it!” instead of “Good job!” Back in my student teaching days, a master teacher observed me with a group of middle school math students. When we sat to review her assessment of my work, she told me that I should use the phrase “you did it” instead of “good job.” I nodded obligingly, and promptly wrote the suggestion off as inconsequential and assessed the difference in phrases to be negligible.
After more than a decade, gobs of professional development hours, and three books by Alfie Kohn (and others), I’ve changed my tune.
Consider the difference: good job is an evaluation. Your good job to my picture of a mountain tells me you approve, and you think it’s worthy of good. It ignores my opinion; after all, whether or not I was pleased with the finished product doesn’t matter with good job. With good job, I learn to value your opinion more than my own and discount my personal feelings about the things I do. Good job keeps me focused on others for their opinions of me.
You did it tells a different story by placing the pride for my work squarely where it belongs: with me. You did it recognizes my effort and grows in me a sense of pride. You did it affirms that I am capable and eliminates unnecessary evaluations. You did it removes the pressure to preform for the evaluation of someone else.
Simple Change #2: Tell a story. Literacy development roots itself in a child’s early years, long before formal schooling begins. Supporting a child’s love for books is something parents and educators do naturally: frequenting libraries, wearing the edges of favorite picture books through repeated readings, and incorporating books into daily routines. But one of the skills that research tells us is foundational to reading is the art of storytelling. Storytelling requires an understanding of the different elements present in a story like characters, plot, conflict, resolution, and setting. Telling a successful story also requires that the narrator establishes enough context to enable the listener to follow along.
Practice storytelling with the children in your lives. Our meal tables often transform into storytelling spaces. As the children eat, I don my storytelling hat and weave language into real and imaginary adventures. Frequently, I solicit character ideas from my table companions, and often, children request repeats from days before. As friends finish eating, they assume the role of storyteller and practice the art for their audience. The most successful stories are told with lots of facial expressions, vocal inflection, and energy – so channel your inner dramatic soul and nurture this key emergent literacy skill.
Simple Change #3: Ask, “How can I help?” Children learn far more from our modeling than our instructions, so one of the surest ways to foster children who are helpful is to show helpfulness. Often our desire to nurture responsibility appears to stand in conflict with our desire to grow helpfulness. Take clean up time, for example. A child who makes a mess should be responsible for cleaning it up, right? After all, it was little Suzie who, in her overly energetic morning rampage, dumped out every basked of toys in the space. If she gets help cleaning it up, she won’t learn to take car of her things, right? After all, I didn’t make the mess. I shouldn’t have to help clean it up. So goes the standard mantra. Our standard mantra is in serious need of an upgrade!
If I resist the urge to saddle the mess-makers with the responsibility, and instead join in the process, I find an immediate response from the whole crew. Helpfulness breeds helpfulness. If I see a child working, I enter alongside and ask, “How can I help?” If I see a child overwhelmed with a large task, I announce, “Help, help! Who can help!” (A line from one of our favorite books, One Duck Stuck.) After all, who likes do manage an overwhelming project alone? Children will remember the feeling of being helped and readily accompany a needy friend in the future.
Simple Change #4: Think inside the box. Open-ended play materials hold the secret to preserving a child’s creativity, imagination, wonder, and love of learning. With no prescribed or “right” way to play, open-ended materials foster cognitive flexibility and persistence. There’s a reason why children would rather play with the box than the toy it came in! Check out fellow educator Denita Dinger for some wonderful open-ended ideas in your work with young children.
Giving your children a box nurtures their development in rich and meaningful ways. Try one or several boxes. Keep your eye out for many different sizes: small ones can be stacked and larger ones function as hiding spaces. Babies and toddlers love to load things into boxes and push them around while older toddlers and preschoolers incorporate boxes into dramatic play. By simply adding a box to your playspace, you open an opportunity for children to grow some of the critical skills they need for lifelong learning.
What small changes do you think are important? I love your thoughts – leave me a note in the comments below!
References:
Curtis, D., & Carter, M. (2008). Learning together with young children: a curriculum framework for reflective teachers. St. Paul, MN: Redleaf Press.
Kohn, A. (1993). Punished by rewards: the trouble with gold stars, incentive plans, A’s, praise, and other bribes. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co.
Pasek, K., Golinkoff, R. M., & Eyer, D. E. (2003). Einstein never used flash cards: how our children really learn–and why they need to play more and memorize less. Emmaus, Pa.: Rodale.
Whitehurst, G., & Lonigan, C. (1998). Child development and emergent literacy. Child Development, 69(3), 848-872.
…………………………………………..
If you enjoyed this, you might like…
Repurposing
“One, Two, Three!” Reflections on Learning through Observation
Raising the Stakes



Hi Emily, thanks for your thought-provoking ideas, I’ve been quite conscious of how many times I say “good job” and “good girl” to my 5yr old and especially my 1yr old this week, since reading your article. It’s fair to say I use it quite a lot
)
I’m wondering how you balance this idea with children’s natural desire for approval from the most important people in their life, their parents?
We hear stories of teenagers and even adults who feel they never really had approval from their parents and either go to all sorts of lengths to reach the ‘elusive prize’, or just feel depressed and rejected.
I understand the benefit in having kids who are secure and take pride in their achievements without the need for our approval, but there must be a balance to be found where as parents we can affirm and boost that confidence by letting them know we approve as well.
Pingback: “You did it!” « Educaring
Dear Emily,
Thank you so much for this article. These four small changes are so simple to implement and do make a huge difference. There is no greater sense of accomplishment and pride than when I see the happiness on my son’s face and his own sense of accomplishment and pride everytime he finally manages to do something that he had been looking forward to achieving and shouts, as he marvels with his arms lifted up in the air “I did it !!! I did it !!!”. It makes me want to cry every single time.
Another small change I would suggest is “Talk less… much, much less”. Let the children do most of the talking, hush the impulse to explain, teach, demonstrate, etc. Let them come up with their own questions and enpower them to find the answers by, for example, asking open-ended questions. That will help to nurture their innate sense of wonder.
Blessings and love,
Sandra
Pingback: 4 Small Changes to Enrich Your Journey With Children « Jasmine Rose
My tip is ‘share the real you’. If you wake up feeling tired and grumpy, say so to the kids. If you’re excited about something, tell the kids. If you’re sad, tell the kids why. Of course, we have to choose appropriate language and give only an appropriate amount of information, but sharing what we really think and feel creates an authenticity that allows children in turn to share their real thoughts and feelings, as well as encouraging the growth of emotional vocabulary and empathy.
Yes, yes, and yes! Thank you so much for taking the time to share your thoughts! I could not agree more – the more emotionally authentic we are for our children, the more they learn emotional integrity for themselves…I don’t think there’s a much more powerful lesson.
“Share the real you!” This is one of the greatest gifts to our children and to ourselves. How can we otherwise expect them to know, respect, celebrate and love thyself?
Once again – You did it, Emily! Thank you for this post and for the many before this one.
You are so welcome! Best to you!
Emily – thank you for yet another wonderful post! I love how you have the ability to synthesize information and share it with parents, childcare professionals, and the broader early childhood community. I have read every one of your posts, and they have completely changed the way in which I approach the young ones I work with, the way I think about their development, and the resources I access to find solutions (like the great list of book you shared above!). You are truly making an incredible impact on this field – even out to the international community! I noticed you are almost at 1000 followers on your Facebook page and at almost 50,000 views on your blog – good work!! Thank you again for all you do on the behalf of those of us who want to provide quality care for children.
I am humbled to see and hear how my work is making a difference. Thank you for taking the time to share, and thank you for reading!
Hi Emily,
I love reading your post and think – well I some of this can apply to adults as well….
You did it, How can I help and getting people to talk and share their stories. Even as adults – we need to practice this kind of language when engaging with people. Often we are always too busy to listen, to offer help. So just wanted to say thanks for letting me reflect on your blog today and how I might use some of these tips either with young children or with the adults I interact with.
Love
Letty
Letty – you are so right! I had a conversation recently with a friend and was sharing some ideas about how she could solve a problem…and realized they were the same words I would give to children who were having a problem. People are people — regardless of age — and we all share common needs for respect and authenticity. Sending you hugs for the important work *you* are doing!! Much love, Emily